Phone card scam debate repeats in LegCo
SingTao · 4 SOURCESabout 6 hours ago6 MIN

Summary
A second Legislative Council oral question in two weeks has put scam-linked phone cards back in focus, after social welfare sector lawmaker Chan Man-yi (陳文宜) asked on Wednesday about legal loopholes around lending or selling registered SIM cards and the timetable for law changes. The Commerce and Economic Development Bureau said it plans to reduce the cap on prepaid SIM registration from 10 to three cards per person per telecom operator and to criminalise several forms of improper use. The government said it aims to launch public consultation with the public and industry in the coming months, while lawmakers also raised concerns about bulk-message “modem pools” and fraud conducted through messaging apps such as WhatsApp and Signal. The back-to-back questions also prompted discussion over whether scarce oral-question slots were being duplicated, although LegCo rules do not bar similar questions in consecutive meetings
Key Points
- Chan Man-yi asked on 18 November about channels through which registered SIM cards reach fraud syndicates, legal liability for lending or selling them, and progress on legislative amendments.
- A week earlier, DAB lawmaker Chu Lap-wai had already questioned the government on phone scams and real-name registration, with overlapping focus on how fraudsters obtain numbers
- Acting commerce minister Bernard Chan Pak-li said the government proposes cutting the prepaid SIM cap from 10 to three per person per telecom operator.
- Officials also propose criminalising, without lawful authority or excuse, using personal data to register others’ SIM cards, and buying, selling, lending or otherwise supplying registered cards.
- Since February 2023, telecom operators have cancelled about 4.2 million prepaid SIM registrations after users failed verification checks requested by the communications regulator.
Why It Matters
For Hong Kong users, the proposed changes could tighten access to prepaid SIM cards while giving police and regulators a more targeted legal basis to pursue people who pass registered cards to fraud rings. The debate in LegCo also shows that, even with broad agreement on the direction of reform, lawmakers are still testing whether the government can deliver measures that go beyond repeating earlier answers.