Yuen Long small-house fraud case permanently stayed
HK01 · 3 SOURCESabout 7 hours ago2 MIN

Summary
A magistrate at Tuen Mun Court permanently stayed proceedings against five indigenous villagers from Shui Tsiu San Tsuen in Yuen Long who had been charged with conspiracy to defraud over small-house licence applications. The court accepted the defence case that senior officials had made a decriminalisation undertaking over breaches related to the disputed statutory declaration terms, with the consequence to be land resumption rather than imprisonment. The five defendants were released in court on 17 November, and on 19 November the magistrate ruled that the prosecution must pay the defence costs. The case is TMCC 144/2025.
Key Points
- The five defendants were Chan Wing-kin, 42, a construction worker; Yeung Kai-kwong, 56, a quality control worker; Lok Tin-lung, 42, a plumber-electrician; Wong Koon-sing, 58, a taxi driver; and Chan Chi-ming, 71, also a taxi driver.
- They each faced one count of conspiracy to defraud, alleging that between 1991 and 2017 they conspired with Yuen Long district councillor Ching Chun-ming and others to mislead the Lands Department in small-house licence applications.
- The prosecution alleged they falsely claimed to be the sole lawful registered owners of the relevant land, inducing the Lands Department to grant licences to build small houses.
- Magistrate Tam Yau-fong said two Lands Department witnesses confirmed the Heung Yee Kuk had objected in 2003 to the statutory declaration wording, and applicants did not need to make the disputed declaration from 2003 to 2006
- The magistrate cited meetings in May 2006 and December 2007, saying officials including then Director of Lands Patrick Lau Lai-chiu, then Permanent Secretary Eva Lau and then development chief Carrie Lam had indicated breaches would be handled by land resumption, not criminal prosecution
Why It Matters
The ruling turns on whether government statements created a legitimate expectation that alleged breaches in the small-house application process would be dealt with administratively rather than through criminal courts. For Hong Kong readers, the costs order on 19 November adds a practical consequence: the court not only halted the case but also required the prosecution to pay the defence's legal costs after finding the proceedings could not continue