business · SingTao

Hotel fine raised to HK$950,000 in pricing cartel appeal

about 8 hours ago5 MIN
Hotel fine raised to HK$950,000 in pricing cartel appeal

Summary

Hong Kong’s Court of Appeal on Thursday allowed the Competition Commission’s appeal and increased the fine imposed on Prudential Hotel (BVI) Limited, owner of Prudential Hotel, from HK$104,000 to HK$950,000 over its role in a pricing cartel. The appellate court said the original penalty failed to reflect the seriousness of the conduct or provide adequate deterrence, and ordered the hotel owner to pay within 42 days as well as the commission’s legal costs

Key Points

  • The appellant was the Competition Commission, while the respondent was Prudential Hotel (BVI) Limited, the company that owns Prudential Hotel
  • The case arose from conduct in 2016, when Kam Lun Travel Company Limited and its managing director, former Travel Industry Council chairman Wu Siu-ying (胡兆英), pressed hotels to align ticket prices with rivals
  • The broader cartel case covered May 2016 to May 2017, involving Kam Lun and Tink Labs Limited selling attraction tickets and coach tickets through hotels in nine hotel groups
  • The Court of Appeal said Prudential Hotel acted as a coordinator and intermediary, relaying Kam Lun’s prices to Tink Labs and asking it to follow the agreed pricing
  • The court held that price-fixing is a serious anti-competitive practice that removes basic price competition, and said the original HK$104,000 fine was even lower than the hotel’s rental income at the time

Why It Matters

The ruling gives the Competition Commission a stronger precedent for arguing that penalties must exceed the gains or practical benefits linked to anti-competitive conduct if they are to deter future breaches. For Hong Kong businesses, it also underlines that even a party described as a facilitator rather than the originator of a cartel can face substantially higher sanctions on appeal.

READ IT IN THE APP

Download on the App Store