local · HK01

Primary school split-marking test row sparks fairness concerns

about 2 hours ago2 MIN
Primary school split-marking test row sparks fairness concerns

Summary

Tung Wah Group of Hospitals Chow Yin Sum Primary School said in a notice to parents on November 20 that differences in how Primary Six General Studies revision was conducted across classes may have indirectly affected the validity and fairness of that part of the assessment, and the current-affairs questions would therefore not count against students' marks. The school said it had reported the matter to the Education Bureau and its sponsoring body, and decided against a resit after considering both fairness and the pressure of repeated examinations on students

Key Points

  • A parent said the Primary Six English split-marking exam was held on November 7, and three days before the paper she found that a “Blue Group” teacher had not distributed a reading comprehension workbook that was within the exam syllabus
  • After retrieving the workbook, the parent said part of the assessed content had been left blank because it had not been fully taught, but the principal told her students had learned similar material and vocabulary elsewhere, so marks would remain unchanged
  • The same parent said 18 students had told their parents that the teacher had not finished teaching the full English exam scope, and she accused the school of failing to address a fairness issue affecting secondary school allocation choices
  • The parent also alleged that in the General Studies exam on November 10, students in Class A received hints from a teacher and generally answered all three extracurricular current-affairs questions correctly, with an average score of 90
  • In its notice issued on November 20, the school acknowledged partial differences in classroom revision methods for the current-affairs section of the Primary Six General Studies exam and said those questions would not lead to mark deductions

Why It Matters

The dispute centres on split-marking assessments, which parents view as important because the results can affect students’ secondary school choices. The Education Bureau said it had contacted the school immediately, required a serious follow-up and a detailed account of its handling, and reminded schools to ensure all internal assessments are conducted fairly and with proper communication and support for parents and students

READ IT IN THE APP

Download on the App Store