crime · Bastillepost

Doctor and businesswoman convicted in vaccine exemption case

about 12 hours ago5 MIN
Doctor and businesswoman convicted in vaccine exemption case

Summary

District Court judge Ernest Lin on Friday convicted registered doctor Tai Kong-shing (戴港盛) and businesswoman Yeung Oi-tung (楊璦瞳) over the improper issuance of Covid-19 vaccine medical exemption certificates, commonly known as “exemption notes”. The court found Tai did not assess patients on their individual medical conditions and issued the certificates solely because consultation fees were paid, while Yeung played an active role in coordinating bookings, pricing and clinic operations. Tai was also convicted on three money-laundering charges involving more than HK$11 million across two Bank of China accounts, and the pair were remanded in custody. The case was adjourned to January 15 for mitigation and sentencing, with background reports ordered.

Key Points

  • Tai and Yeung were jointly convicted of obtaining access to a computer with dishonest intent to gain for themselves or others, over conduct between February 10 and September 20, 2022.
  • Tai had faced 13 alternative computer-access charges linked to individual certificates, but the judge said those did not need to be dealt with after conviction on the main count.
  • The judge said the clinic operation exploited anti-epidemic rules and citizens seeking vaccine exemptions, with consultation fees ranging from HK$1,000 to HK$4,000.
  • Police evidence showed that in about seven months, Tai issued 3,751 exemption certificates to 3,462 people, including 1,664 in September 2022 alone.
  • Seven recipients, including undercover police officers, testified they obtained certificates without detailed consultation or proof of illness, and one woman got one for her absent son.

Why It Matters

The ruling sets out how the court viewed the use of medical exemption certificates during Hong Kong’s pandemic controls, especially where clinical judgment was replaced by payment-driven processing. For Hong Kong readers, the case also underlines the legal risks for both medical practitioners and non-medical operators involved in handling official health-related records and related proceeds.

READ IT IN THE APP

Download on the App Store