Court rejects Alan Hoo deed-entry judicial review
HK01 · 3 SOURCESabout 7 hours ago2 MIN

Summary
The High Court on Thursday rejected senior counsel Alan Hoo’s judicial review concerning a land registration entry arising from a Buildings Department demolition order over alleged unauthorised structures at his Pok Fu Lam property. Mr Justice Russell Coleman held that the Buildings Department had no discretionary power to remove the registration, and that such a decision could only be made by a court. Although Hoo had applied to withdraw the case before the hearing, the court decided the application should be dismissed instead and ordered him to pay the respondent’s costs. The ruling followed an earlier, separate judicial review in which both sides agreed that the Appeal Tribunal (Buildings) had jurisdiction to deal with Hoo’s constitutional challenge to the demolition order.
Key Points
- The applicant was Alan Hoo, identified in the proceedings as Hoo Alan, while the respondent was the Director of Buildings or intended respondent Building Authority, according to the reports.
- The dispute concerned a detached house at Hoi Yat House on Sassoon Road, Pok Fu Lam, which Hoo bought in 1996 and moved into in 2015.
- The Buildings Department issued a demolition order last year over alleged unauthorised building works, and the order was then registered against the property at the Land Registry.
- Hoo said illness had left him unable to practise and facing heavy medical, family and chambers rental expenses, so he wanted a second mortgage after removing the entry.
- The judge accepted the department’s public-interest argument that owners have no right to demand removal of such an entry from the department, because only a court can do so.
Why It Matters
The ruling clarifies for Hong Kong property owners that a challenge to a demolition order cannot be repackaged as a demand that the Buildings Department “unilaterally” remove a land registration entry. It also underlines the costs risk in judicial review when an applicant withdraws after the respondent has set out a clear legal position and the court finds the claim lacked a proper basis.